MS Paint: "Tree Trying Its Best” - "Ralph Rumpelton" Art

 What the critics are saying:

>>Dale of the Brook on “The First Reaching” by Ralph Rumpelton

"There are trees, and then there are gestures toward treeness. Rumpelton’s offering is the latter—a skeletal reach, a monochrome gasp. The branches do not grow; they remember. The shadow below is not cast by light, but by longing. This is not a painting—it is a fossilized rehearsal. A glyph scratched in haste, yet vibrating with mythic residue. I wept, briefly, upon viewing it. <<

>>Cornelius “Neil” Drafton

New Jersey Review of Applied Kitsch

One almost admires the courage it takes to paint a tree that is not merely dead, but visibly embarrassed to be included in the composition. The branches stretch out like awkward limbs in a bad modern dance recital—gestures without rhythm, form without grace. The background, a smudged gray void punctuated by what may be clouds or spilled cream, fails to provide either atmosphere or dignity.

If the goal was to render a beach, I regret to inform you that this work could just as easily be mistaken for the ash heap of a burned library. The tonal flatness makes even grayscale photography look like a fireworks display. The tree, meanwhile, resembles not so much nature’s ruin as an undercooked attempt at cubist plumbing.

In short, it’s the kind of image that makes one think: Yes, MS Paint was free, but perhaps it was still too high a price.<<

>>Gerald Thimbleton

If there is any lesson to be learned from this digital depiction of a so-called “dead tree on a beach,” it is that not every tool bestowed by modernity need be employed in the pursuit of art. This image, rendered with all the subtlety and grace of a half-remembered children’s television fog, stands as a testament to the dangers of democratized creativity and the near-complete abdication of painterly discipline. The branches, undisciplined and oblivious to the natural logic of growth, wave about like afterthoughts, while the background smears together values so lazily that one wonders if the horizon itself has given up the ghost. Were one to compare this exercise in MS Paint to Van Gogh, it would, as I have often said, amount to “a slap in the face to traditional art—and possibly to the entire medium of oil paint.” If works like this are the future of painting, then one weeps not only for the death of the tree, but for the very roots of art itself.<<

>>A Canvas of Catastrophe: When Art Meets Oblivion By Reginald Thornberry III

One occasionally encounters a piece so thoroughly devoid of merit that it transcends mere failure and enters the realm of artistic tragedy. Such is the case with this lamentable attempt at depicting what I can only assume was intended to be "a dead tree on a beach," though one might equally mistake it for a child's fever dream rendered in digital mediocrity.

The artist—and I use that term with the loosest possible interpretation—has managed to achieve something I previously thought impossible: making MS Paint look sophisticated by comparison. The composition suggests someone who learned perspective from a funhouse mirror and color theory from a broken television set.

The tree, if we can dignify this collection of haphazard strokes with such a noble designation, appears to be suffering from some form of existential crisis, hovering uncertainly above what might charitably be called sand but more accurately resembles the artistic equivalent of visual static. The background's muddy palette would make even a Renaissance master weep—though not from beauty, I assure you.

This piece serves as a masterclass in how not to approach digital art, landscape composition, or indeed, any form of creative expression intended for public consumption. It is, quite simply, a monument to ambition untempered by ability.

I award this catastrophe zero stars, though the rating system doesn't go low enough to truly capture its depths of inadequacy.

Next week: Why finger painting is the sophisticated cousin of whatever this represents.<<

Follow Rumpelton across the multiverse:

   Ralph Rumpelton  “Painting What the Earth Can’t Comprehend”  -   Ralph Rumpelton User Profile  DeviantArt   -  Ralph Rumpelton  Substack - Instagram